Are Pokémon Cards at Walmart and Target Fake? Retail Fakes and Resealed Packs Explained

PullBull TeamUpdated 10 min read
Sealed Pokémon booster packs and a blister pack on a store shelf, with one pack held up to the light to check the crimp seal

You grab a few booster packs or a blister from the card aisle at Walmart or Target, rip them open at home, and something feels off. The pull rate seems strange, the pack looked a little loose, or a card does not feel like the others in your binder. So you start wondering: are the Pokémon cards at big retail stores fake?

The short answer is that the products big retailers stock on their own shelves normally come through official distribution, so a fake product sitting in the card aisle is not the usual problem. The real risks at retail are different, and they are worth understanding: resealed or tampered packs, products that were returned and put back on the shelf, and third-party sellers on retailer websites. This guide explains each one, shows you how to check a pack before you pay, and covers what to do if you think you got a bad one.

Are store-bought Pokémon cards real?

When a major retailer buys Pokémon TCG products for its own stores, it usually buys them through official distribution channels. That is why most collectors treat sealed product bought in person from a big retailer as a lower-risk source than a random online listing.

Lower risk is not zero risk, though. Problems at retail usually come from what happens to a product after it reaches the store, not from the store ordering fake stock. The three situations collectors talk about most are:

  • Resealed or tampered packs. Someone opens packs, removes the valuable cards, and puts the packs or a box back on the shelf.
  • Returned products. Someone buys a product, swaps the contents or removes cards, and returns it. If the return is not checked carefully, it can end up back on the shelf.
  • Third-party marketplace sellers. Some retailer websites let outside sellers list products. Those listings are not the same as products sold and shipped by the retailer itself.

Knowing which one you are dealing with tells you what to look for.

Resealed packs: the most common retail worry

A resealed pack is a booster pack that was opened, searched or emptied, and then closed again to look new. People do this to keep the rare cards and sell the rest as if they were untouched.

Some methods collectors describe include weighing packs to guess which ones hold heavier holo or rare cards, slitting a pack along the back seam, or opening the crimp and sealing it again with glue or heat. Blister packs and boxes can be opened at the back or the bottom and closed with tape or glue.

You will not catch every resealed pack, but most of them leave clues if you look closely before you buy.

How to check a booster pack before you buy

Take a few seconds with each pack. Hold it under the store light and check these points.

1. Look at the top and bottom crimps

The crimp is the sealed, ridged strip at the top and bottom of the pack. On an untouched pack it should look even and consistent from one side to the other. Be careful with packs where:

  • The ridges look flattened, melted, uneven or crooked.
  • One crimp looks different from the other.
  • You can see glue, shiny residue or a gap in the seal.

2. Check the back seam

Most booster packs have a long seam down the back. It should be straight and fully sealed. A seam that is wavy, lifting, wrinkled or partly open is a warning sign.

3. Feel the pack

An untouched pack is usually snug around the cards. A pack that feels loose, has extra air inside, or lets the cards slide around a lot may have been opened. Wrinkles or creases in strange places can also be a sign.

4. Compare it with the packs next to it

If you are not sure, compare the pack with others of the same set on the shelf. A single pack that looks different from the rest, in its crimp, its seam or its shape, is the one to leave behind.

5. Check boxes and blisters too

For blister packs, check that the plastic bubble is firmly sealed to the cardboard with no tape, glue or lifted edges. For boxes such as Elite Trainer Boxes, check the shrink wrap. Factory wrap is usually tight and neat. Loose, baggy, torn or messy wrap with odd folds is worth a second look. Also check the bottom and the back of the box, since those are the easiest places to open without it being obvious.

What about fake cards at retail?

Counterfeit Pokémon cards do exist, and they are a real problem in the hobby. They are much more common in cheap online listings, bulk lots, unbranded bundles and products from unknown sellers than in official sealed product on a big retailer's own shelf.

If you ever pull a card that looks wrong, these are quick checks you can do at home:

  • Card stock and feel. Fakes often feel thinner, glossier or flimsier than real cards.
  • Font and text. Look for spelling mistakes, odd fonts, wrong spacing or text that does not match other cards from the same set.
  • Colors and print. Washed-out or overly dark colors, blurry printing, or a holo pattern that looks wrong are common signs.
  • The back of the card. The blue back of a fake card is often the wrong shade or has a blurry print.
  • Compare with a known real card. Put it next to a card you know is genuine from the same set.

For a full walkthrough with more checks, see our guide on how to spot fake Pokémon cards.

Buying on retailer websites: check who the seller is

This is the point many people miss. Some big retailer websites include listings from outside sellers alongside products the retailer sells itself. A listing on a well-known site is not automatically the same as buying from that retailer directly.

Before you order online:

  • Look for who the product is sold by and shipped by. That information is normally shown on the product page.
  • Be careful with prices that are far below what the same product usually sells for.
  • Read the seller's reviews and return policy before you buy.
  • Avoid listings with stock photos only, vague descriptions, or names that do not match an official product.

If the seller is an outside business you do not know, treat the listing with the same care you would give any other online seller.

Signs you may have opened a bad pack

You cannot always tell before opening. After you open a pack, these are signs that something may be wrong:

  • The cards are in a different order than you normally see from that set.
  • The pack contains fewer cards than usual.
  • The cards are bent, scratched or out of place in a way that does not fit a sealed pack.
  • There are cards from a different set mixed in.

A pack with no hit is not proof it was searched. Rare cards are rare, and plenty of untouched packs contain nothing special. Look for physical signs of tampering, not just bad luck.

What to do if you think you bought a resealed or fake product

Keep everything. Keep the wrapper, the cards and your receipt. Do not throw away the packaging.

Take photos. Photograph the crimps, the seam and the contents straight on and in good light. Our guide on how to photograph trading cards shows how to get clear shots.

Contact the store. Go back to the customer service desk with your receipt, or contact the retailer if you bought online. Policies differ by store and by location, so ask what they can do.

If you bought from a third-party seller, contact the seller through the platform you used and follow that platform's dispute process.

How to lower your risk when buying Pokémon cards

  • Buy sealed product from stores and sellers you trust, and check every pack before you pay.
  • Skip packs that look different from others on the shelf, even if it is the last one.
  • For valuable singles, consider buying the card itself instead of chasing it in packs. You can see the exact card, its condition and its photos before you commit. If you are working out what a card should cost, read how much are my Pokémon cards worth?
  • Consider graded cards for expensive buys. A card in a slab from a major grading company has already been checked by that grader. See PSA vs CGC vs BGS for Pokémon cards to compare them.
  • Ask online sellers for clear front and back photos and compare them with known real copies.
  • Set a maximum price before you bid in auctions, so excitement does not push you into overpaying. Our guide on how to win online card auctions explains how.

Buying singles on PullBull

PullBull is a collector-focused marketplace built around timed auctions and seller stores, where buyers can browse listings, watch auctions and follow the stores they like. PullBull is in an early, pre-launch stage, so listings are still limited. Paid checkout and payment protection are not active yet. Buyers and sellers use the contact seller button to agree on payment, packing and postage before going ahead, so always ask for clear photos and check a card carefully before you agree to anything. Learn more in what is PullBull? and how online card auctions work.

FAQ

Are Pokémon cards at Walmart and Target fake? Products a big retailer stocks on its own shelves normally come through official distribution, so fake products in the card aisle are not the usual problem. The bigger risks are resealed or tampered packs, returned products put back on the shelf, and third-party sellers on retailer websites.

How can you tell if a Pokémon pack has been resealed? Check the top and bottom crimps for uneven, flattened or glued ridges, check that the back seam is straight and fully sealed, and feel for a loose pack. Compare it with other packs from the same set on the shelf.

Why do people reseal Pokémon packs? To keep the valuable cards and sell or return the rest as if it were untouched.

Can you tell which packs have rare cards by weighing them? Some people have tried weighing packs to guess which ones hold heavier holo cards. This is one reason collectors are careful about loose packs on open shelves. It is not a fair way to shop, and it leaves the remaining packs less likely to contain hits.

Is a pack with no rare cards a resealed pack? Not necessarily. Rare cards are rare, and many untouched packs have no big hit. Look for physical signs of tampering, such as a damaged crimp, an open seam or cards in the wrong order.

What should I do if I bought a resealed pack? Keep the wrapper, cards and receipt, take clear photos, and contact the store or the seller. Return policies differ, so ask what they can do.

Are Pokémon cards sold on retailer websites always official? Not always. Some retailer websites include listings from outside sellers. Check who the item is sold by and shipped by before you order.

Bottom line

Pokémon cards on a big retailer's own shelves are usually real, but that does not mean every pack is untouched. Resealed packs, returned products and third-party online sellers are the risks to watch. Check the crimps, the seam and the feel of every pack, compare it with the others on the shelf, keep your receipt, and check any card that looks wrong. For expensive cards, buying the single, or a graded copy, lets you see exactly what you are paying for. When you are ready to browse cards, visit PullBull.

Ready to find your next card?

Browse live auctions and listings on PullBull.

Browse Pokémon card auctions on PullBull

Related articles